Ethical Investing: Overview and How to Do It
Key takeaways
* Ethical investing uses personal moral or ethical values to guide investment choices.
* It can mean excluding certain industries (e.g., gambling, tobacco, firearms) or favoring companies with positive social or environmental impacts.
* Ethical selection does not guarantee better financial returns.
* Due diligence should include both financial analysis and verification that a company’s actions match its stated values.
Explore More Resources
What is ethical investing?
Ethical investing (also called values-based or socially conscious investing) means choosing securities based on ethical principles. Unlike standardized socially responsible funds, which follow a single set of screening rules, ethical investing is often personalized: investors select what to exclude or prioritize according to their own beliefs—religious, environmental, social, or political.
Why it matters
Ethical investing lets individuals direct capital to companies and projects that align with their values. It can be motivated by:
* Religious precepts (e.g., avoiding alcohol, gambling, pork-related businesses).
* Environmental concerns (e.g., avoiding fossil fuels, favoring clean energy).
* Social justice and labor standards.
* Governance and corporate behavior.
Explore More Resources
A common practice is avoiding “sin stocks”—companies whose primary activities are widely considered harmful, such as gambling, tobacco, alcohol, or firearms.
Brief history
* 18th century: Religious groups such as Quakers avoided supporting the slave trade.
* 18th–19th century: Religious leaders (e.g., John Wesley) urged avoiding investments that harm others.
* Islamic finance: Prohibits interest (riba) and investments in alcohol, gambling, and other forbidden activities; some mutual funds follow these principles.
* 1960s–70s: Social movements shifted focus to civil rights, labor, and opposition to war.
* 1990s onward: Environmental issues and sustainability became central; more focus today on climate and social impact.
Explore More Resources
How to invest ethically — practical steps
1. Define your values
* List industries, activities, and business practices you want to exclude or prioritize.
* Decide whether your focus is environmental, social, governance, religious, or a mix.
- Choose an approach
- Negative screening: exclude companies or sectors (e.g., tobacco, fossil fuels).
- Positive screening: invest in companies with strong social or environmental records.
- Best-in-class: select leaders within sectors for ESG performance.
- Thematic or impact investing: target specific outcomes (renewable energy, affordable housing).
- Shareholder engagement: vote proxies and push for corporate change.
-
Faith-based funds: follow religiously defined rules.
-
Select investment vehicles
- Individual stocks or bonds (requires more research).
- Mutual funds or ETFs labeled SRI/ESG/impact (check methodologies).
- Green bonds or community development investments.
-
Faith-based or halal investment products if following religious guidelines.
-
Do financial and ethical due diligence
- Review financial health, earnings history, and future outlook.
- Verify corporate practices: sustainability reports, third-party audits, controversies, and litigation.
-
Use reputable ESG ratings and research, but understand rating differences and limitations.
-
Watch for greenwashing
- Don’t rely solely on mission statements—companies may claim ethical goals without corresponding behavior.
-
Look for measurable targets, transparent reporting, and verified third-party certifications.
-
Monitor and adjust
- Reassess holdings regularly to ensure continued alignment with your values and financial goals.
- Track both impact and financial performance.
Common pitfalls and considerations
* No performance guarantee: Ethical constraints can affect diversification and returns positively or negatively.
* Subjectivity: What’s “ethical” varies by investor; clear definitions help consistent decisions.
* Inconsistent data: ESG ratings and definitions differ among providers.
* Corporate hypocrisy: Companies may issue ethical statements while engaging in contrary practices—research and scrutiny are essential.
Explore More Resources
Quick checklist before investing
* Have I clearly defined what I will exclude and what I want to support?
* Does this investment meet my financial objectives and risk tolerance?
* Can I verify the company’s ethical claims through independent reporting or metrics?
* Am I comfortable with the potential impact of exclusions on portfolio diversification?
Conclusion
Ethical investing lets you align investment capital with personal values, but it requires defining priorities, careful research, and ongoing monitoring. Balance ethical goals with sound financial analysis, and be vigilant against superficial claims to ensure your investments reflect both your values and financial objectives.