What is a total return index?
A total return index measures the performance of a group of securities by combining capital appreciation (price changes) with the reinvestment of all cash distributions, such as dividends and interest. Unlike a price return index, which tracks only price movements, a total return index reflects the compound effect of reinvesting payouts and thus gives a fuller picture of investor outcomes.
How total return indexes work
- Total return = price change + reinvested distributions.
- When cash payouts (dividends, coupon payments) are received, the index assumes they are immediately reinvested in the index components.
- Reinvestment amplifies long-term growth because distributions generate their own subsequent returns (compounding).
- Total return treatment applies to equity and bond indexes: equity indexes reinvest dividends; bond indexes reinvest coupon payments and redemptions.
Example: if a security gains 6% in price and pays a 4% yield, the total return for the period is roughly 10% (6% price gain + 4% reinvested yield). If price falls 4% while yield is 4%, total return can be near zero.
Explore More Resources
Examples
- S&P 500 Total Return Index (SPTR): includes dividends in performance, unlike the standard S&P 500 price index (SPX).
- Other total return indexes: Dow Jones Industrials Total Return Index (DJITR), Russell 2000 Total Return.
Historical illustrations show the impact of reinvested dividends: for example, one major S&P 500 ETF’s price-only return since inception was several hundred percent, while its total-return (dividends reinvested) return was roughly double that amount. Over multi-year periods, including dividends can materially increase reported returns.
Price return vs. total return — key differences
- Scope: Price return = only price changes. Total return = price changes + reinvested cash distributions.
- Reported performance: Total return will always be equal to or greater than price return (assuming nonnegative distributions).
- Use cases: Price return is useful for tracking market level movement; total return is better for evaluating actual investor experience and compound growth.
How index funds relate
- Index funds seek to replicate the performance of an index (price or total return) by holding the underlying securities or a representative sample.
- Funds that aim to match a total return index will reinvest distributions or reflect them in NAV, producing performance closer to the index’s total return.
- Index funds generally require less active management, which often leads to lower fees and broad diversification.
Takeaways
- A total return index provides a more complete measure of investment performance by accounting for both capital gains and reinvested distributions.
- Including dividends and interest materially increases long-term returns due to compounding.
- When comparing investments or evaluating historical performance, use total return figures to understand the likely investor experience.